Blogging Against Disablism Day
I generally write about crafts here, but when I heard about Blogging Against Disablism Day, I knew it was something I had to participate in. I've always heard the term ableism (or ablism) rather than disablism, but they seem to mean the same thing: discrimination in favour of able-bodied people. There are many aspects to this issue, and I'll only address a small part of those that affect me personally.
While more places are accessible to those who can't climb stairs now than in past decades, there are still an awful lot of places that are not at all accessible. This is obviously something that needs to change in time. But in the mean time, I'd like to see all public venues provide clear information about their accessibility or lack thereof. I'd like to see it posted upfront, on publicity materials, on the outside of buildings, on web sites, on telephone recordings at businesses. And I want the information to be accurate: don't tell me it's accessible if it's not. Don't tell me your hotel is "totally accessible" if the washrooms are not accessible -- do you think people are going to stay for the weekend but not use the washroom?!
Every time I want to go somewhere new, it's up to me to try to obtain accessibility information. Sometimes I can get it quickly, by phoning a place. Other times, it's much harder: I've left phone or email messages, and never heard back, or not heard back until it's too late. It strikes me as ridiculous that every time any person who needs accessibility information wants it, we have to phone or call or write or show up and hope for the best. Business advertising always includes basic information like address and contact details. Often it includes hours and a list of services provided. Why not include access information?
And when community groups put on events, make access a priority. If it's not a priority, be honest about that. I'd rather hear, "our event is not fully accessible -- we're holding it in a place with stairs," than hear nothing at all and have to spend time searching for this information. Worse is when people tell me that, "of course it's fully accessible," and then I show up and find out it's not.
I'd like to see details: if you're not fully accessible, then don't claim to be. And if you fall short of full accessibility, describe everything. There are a lot of us who can in fact manage partially accessible spaces, and you're losing our participation if you don't provide the details. If you have stairs, tell me if you have two steps or two flights of stairs. If the washroom is small but has grab bars, say so.
Don't get me wrong: I'm not saying this is good enough. I still want all places to become properly accessible. But having this information -- about partial or total lack of accessibility -- would really cut down on the frustration I and many others feel about trying to find out these details. I can't tell you how often I've phoned a business and asked questions about these things, only to be greeted with completely bewilderment, ignorance or hostility. Staff in any business, community centre, government office, etc., should be trained to give out this basic information. Examples of situations I should NOT have had to encounter:
- At the community centre where I wanted to exercise, I asked whether there was another route down to the fitness equipment room besides down a long flight of stairs. The answer was no. When I asked why there was no elevator down for those who were disabled, the staff person laughed and said, "the equipment is for working out on. I don't think disabled people can do that anyway, right?" I used the stairs, laboriously, on crutches, every day for several weeks, and suffered damage to my knees as a result. Just as my membership expired, I found out that I could have made special arrangements to enter the building on the lower floor and avoided these stairs all along.
- I tried to make a reservation at a campground, and when I asked if the site was fit for wheelchairs, had someone yell at me that "those people" can't go camping anyway and then hang up on me. When I finally found an accessible campground, I was delighted. I made sure that the grounds and the public washrooms were all accessible. Yes, I was told, it was not only accessible, but washroom had a wonderful large shower with seats and everything. Hooray! When I arrived, I found that the only entrance to the washroom was up two large steps.
- A local group regularly rented a hall to put on parties, but their preferred location was inaccessible. Finally, after much arguing and discussion over a couple of years, the group decided to rent an accessible space. Yay! When I arrived, the accessible entrance was locked and unstaffed. At the main entrance, at the bottom of a flight of stairs, was a sign telling me that the event was accessible, and all I had to do was ask a friend or volunteer to go up the stairs and ask to have the other door opened. (Because, you know, us gimps aren't fit to go anywhere on our own. Not like we might arrive alone, and not have anyone to send up the stairs, right?) After much hollering and going back and forth between the entrances, I finally had someone come out and arrange to let me in the other door. Once inside, I headed for the washroom, only to find that the only accessible stall was out of order and taped shut.
When these things happen, the ramifications for the person with disabilities can be severe. From the perspective of the business owner or community organizer, it may not be a big deal. They may experience a moment of regret that they couldn't meet everyone's needs. But for the person who has shown up only to be excluded, or left in a dangerous or unhealthy situation, it's a really big deal. We're all members of society, and none of us should be left out. Even a small amount of thought and effort will make a big difference. And maybe, if everyone has to acknowledge the lack of accessibility every day, businesses and community groups will be more motivated to make places properly accessible rather than accepting the status quo.

13 comments:
Hi!
A very interesting read! Thanks for writing it! Hope lots more people will read it!
(BTW I am a "crafting person" who never blogs about it!) Chris
Oh so true. Or the bathroom that has bars stuck in there... but is too narrow to get a wheelchair in.
WCD
You just made me stop and think about the accessibility of my workplace; it's pretty good with the exception of the fact that the front entrance doesn't have one of those little square buttons you can push to open the double doors automatically.
But on the good side, other than that, I can now think of exactly how to give directions to my workplace to someone in a wheelchair so they could come upstairs and see us. :-) Where "come upstairs" is defined as "get the elevator" of course. Oh, and the bathroom has one of those enormous stalls with the grab-bars, so that's good.
That was a great post! And so true. So many people don't know what accessibility is (and it can vary so much from person to person - I think making things wheelchair accessible is a good starting point). Bathrooms are my nightmare. Even most "accessible" bathrooms have doors too narrow for my wheelchair, not enough room to turn around, or doors I can't pull closed. It's a little degrading, having to struggle with something that should be simpler.
It really sucks when you're told that something is totally accessible, especially a social event, and you show up to find stairs. It puts the spotlight on you and creates an embarrassing situation. People stare at you and it makes you feel like you don't belong there. These physical barriers aren't just inconvenient, they cause social isolation.
You know... years ago black people were relegated to sitting in the back of the bus, or using certain entrances or drinking fountains... and that wasn't okay and people fought back against it. But as a woman in a wheelchair I'm segregated to a different entrance, a different drinking fountain and sometimes different busses. Why isn't there a civil rights march against that?
Oh, the absurdity of each of these situations! How frustrating! And how frustrating to encounter so much ignorance. It really does feel like an insurmountable wall sometimes.
I love the idea of having to clearly post accessibility features and alternate routes.
Great post. The "only accessible if you have a friend to go up the stairs and ask" thing is a pet peeve of mine. It makes me so angry for my girlfriend every time I have to do that for her, and I shudder to think what would happen if she were there alone.
Great post.
I've often thought that instead of that little access sign marking out supposedly accessible venues, entrances or restrooms, there should be a sign of shame, sort of like a Good Housekeeping Seal but in reverse: "This place discriminates and does not meet legal access codes!" (Or something pithier.)
Instead of marking out places where we can go, which, lets face it, if everyone actually followed the law this would be redundant, our rights should be presumed rhetorically in signage that spotlights who fails.
Oh how I agree: the only thing worse than some place that inaccessible, is some place that SAYS it's accessible but ISN'T. Because then, I've gone to all the trouble to get there, set aside the time and energy to leave the house to do this specific thing, only to find that I... can't. GRRR. (Even friends houses - all that would've been necessary in a lot of cases was some warning - "Well there's only 2 small steps"; "Well the bathroom's kinda narrow"; "Well we have a dog but I can put him in another room." Even if it meant I couldn't go, I'd still rather make an informed decision rather than suffer the consequences.)
Thanks, everyone, for your comments!
Chris, thanks for your comment. What kind of crafts do you do?
Wheelchair Dancer, yes, the supposedly accessible but ridiculously tiny washrooms are terrible.
Janiscortese, so glad my post helped in some way. And good to hear your workplace is accessible.
The Angry Gimp, yes, I agree with you that accessibility varies highly, and that wheelchair access is just one place to start. It's one that I notice, because I've used a chair in the past, and I walk with crutches and need many of the same things (ramps, no stairs, grab bars, no heavy doors, etc.) I'd really love to see all types of accessibility addressed everywhere.
Cholla, excellent point. There should be a civil rights march for this, indeed.
Saraarts, yes, it gets pretty overwhelming at times. I go in phases, where I have energy to deal with it all, and where I just need to sit back and take a break because it's too much work.
Willendort5761, thanks for your feedback! And I loved your post on the topic -- it was great to hear about things from the perspective of a partner.
Kay Olson, I like your perspective on this. That is a fabulous idea!
Never That Easy, yes, yes, that's exactly it. I want to make an informed decision. I want all the information up front. It amazes me how blithely people say, "oh yes, this place is totally accessible!" without mentioning the "just one or two steps" or bathroom up a flight of stairs, etc.
I've seen some pretty stupid access stuff myself, but the examples in this post take the cake.
I've seen a lift at the top of a flight of six steps, a button (marked with little picture of a wheelchair) that opened a door at the top of three big steps, and an "accessible entrance" that led through a maze of narrow, twisting passages, complete with heavy doors. My local swimming pool has a rear entrance for wheelchairs level with the ground floor, but the pay point is up a flight of steps. The list of stupidities goes on and on.
Like Kay Olsen, I've often wanted to put a little "no wheelchairs allowed" sign on the doors of inaccessible shops and other public venues. It could go alongside the other signs starting "No ...". No dogs (except for assistance dogs), No smoking, No food or drink, No bicycles - No wheelchairs.
And, as cholla pointed out, it is no longer acceptable to hang a sign saying "No Jews, no Blacks, no Irish". Quite right, too. But it is still OK to hang out the unwritten sign "No wheelchairs". Every time a place is inaccessible the message that is sent out is clear: "we don't want your sort in here." People who would never dream of using those words will quite happily "say" them through their actions - or lack of action.
Sorry, this has turned from a comment into a sort of mini-post of its own. I'll shut up now.
As the able-bodied caretaker of a person with disabilities, I know that I am often angered by the simple problem of aisles in stores that are too narrow for a push chair, never mind a self-propelled chair, which I believe would be a bit wider. The aisle has frequently started out wide enough, but displays and piled merchandise make it impassable. This happens even in supermarkets, where really, there is enough space and there should be no excuse.
I am willing to give a break to historic locations, because I know from experience that not every place can easily be modified. There was a museum my person wanted to visit on location, but it was in a building over 150 years old. The only way I can see to make that building truly accessible is to put a new tower alongside it so an elevator can be put in. In these cases what would be necessary is funding for the job - it is a very different thing than a ramp up several stairs or widening one doorway. However, when I called the person I spoke to was apologetic, explained what they *could* do (show certain portable artifacts, use a special book they have made up with comprehensive pictures of the display area, etc) and gave detailed info on how difficult it would or would not be to get to the "ground floor" of the place. (Here in the East it is not uncommon to find that older buildings had two entrances, one well below grade level, and one well above. Thus, there is no real ground floor.)I felt that was a reasonable compromise in a situation where clearly, it was not economically feasable for them to be totally accessible. The sense that they wanted to accomodate and could not went a long way with me.
What my person, who has limited communication, felt, I cannot say with any certainty. There was disappointment, I do know that.
That anyone, at this point in time, should be saying "Those people" about anyone is ridiculous. People who don't know what accessible means should ask what one needs and then describe the building.
Of course, I am able bodied, and as such perhaps my opinion here does not quite carry the same weight. It is not myself I have to be frustrated for.
Thanks to Kewryta and Gryffinitter for your comments that came in a bit later than the original batch. The topic brings up so much for many of us, and personally I think that the "rants" are entirely reasonable and justified, and I'm glad to have them in this space!
My thanks again to all who have read and commented here. Blogging Against Disablism Day is a wonderful opportunity to connect with all sorts of amazing people with perspectives on disability and discrimination. I loved going about to various of the posts in the days and weeks following that day and learning a lot from different writers.
Post a Comment